[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [Xen-devel] [PATCH for-4.13 2/2] Rationalize max_grant_frames and max_maptrack_frames handling


  • To: "Durrant, Paul" <pdurrant@xxxxxxxxxx>, Ian Jackson <ian.jackson@xxxxxxxxxx>
  • From: Hans van Kranenburg <hans@xxxxxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Wed, 27 Nov 2019 23:32:26 +0100
  • Autocrypt: addr=hans@xxxxxxxxxxx; keydata= mQINBFo2pooBEADwTBe/lrCa78zuhVkmpvuN+pXPWHkYs0LuAgJrOsOKhxLkYXn6Pn7e3xm+ ySfxwtFmqLUMPWujQYF0r5C6DteypL7XvkPP+FPVlQnDIifyEoKq8JZRPsAFt1S87QThYPC3 mjfluLUKVBP21H3ZFUGjcf+hnJSN9d9MuSQmAvtJiLbRTo5DTZZvO/SuQlmafaEQteaOswme DKRcIYj7+FokaW9n90P8agvPZJn50MCKy1D2QZwvw0g2ZMR8yUdtsX6fHTe7Ym+tHIYM3Tsg 2KKgt17NTxIqyttcAIaVRs4+dnQ23J98iFmVHyT+X2Jou+KpHuULES8562QltmkchA7YxZpT mLMZ6TPit+sIocvxFE5dGiT1FMpjM5mOVCNOP+KOup/N7jobCG15haKWtu9k0kPz+trT3NOn gZXecYzBmasSJro60O4bwBayG9ILHNn+v/ZLg/jv33X2MV7oYXf+ustwjXnYUqVmjZkdI/pt 30lcNUxCANvTF861OgvZUR4WoMNK4krXtodBoEImjmT385LATGFt9HnXd1rQ4QzqyMPBk84j roX5NpOzNZrNJiUxj+aUQZcINtbpmvskGpJX0RsfhOh2fxfQ39ZP/0a2C59gBQuVCH6C5qsY rc1qTIpGdPYT+J1S2rY88AvPpr2JHZbiVqeB3jIlwVSmkYeB/QARAQABtCZIYW5zIHZhbiBL cmFuZW5idXJnIDxoYW5zQGtub3JyaWUub3JnPokCTgQTAQoAOBYhBOJv1o/B6NS2GUVGTueB VzIYDCpVBQJaNq7KAhsDBQsJCAcDBRUKCQgLBRYCAwEAAh4BAheAAAoJEOeBVzIYDCpVgDMQ ANSQMebh0Rr6RNhfA+g9CKiCDMGWZvHvvq3BNo9TqAo9BC4neAoVciSmeZXIlN8xVALf6rF8 lKy8L1omocMcWw7TlvZHBr2gZHKlFYYC34R2NvxS0xO8Iw5rhEU6paYaKzlrvxuXuHMVXgjj bM3zBiN8W4b9VW1MoynP9nvm1WaGtFI9GIyK9j6mBCU+N5hpvFtt4DBmuWjzdDkd3sWUufYd nQhGimWHEg95GWhQUiFvr4HRvYJpbjRRRQG3O/5Fm0YyTYZkI5CDzQIm5lhqKNqmuf2ENstS 8KcBImlbwlzEpK9Pa3Z5MUeLZ5Ywwv+d11fyhk53aT9bipdEipvcGa6DrA0DquO4WlQR+RKU ywoGTgntwFu8G0+tmD8J1UE6kIzFwE5kiFWjM0rxv1tAgV9ZWqmp3sbI7vzbZXn+KI/wosHV iDeW5rYg+PdmnOlYXQIJO+t0KmF5zJlSe7daylKZKTYtk7w1Fq/Oh1Rps9h1C4sXN8OAUO7h 1SAnEtehHfv52nPxwZiI6eqbvqV0uEEyLFS5pCuuwmPpC8AmOrciY2T8T+4pmkJNO2Nd3jOP cnJgAQrxPvD7ACp/85LParnoz5c9/nPHJB1FgbAa7N5d8ubqJgi+k9Q2lAL9vBxK67aZlFZ0 Kd7u1w1rUlY12KlFWzxpd4TuHZJ8rwi7PUceuQINBFo2sK8BEADSZP5cKnGl2d7CHXdpAzVF 6K4Hxwn5eHyKC1D/YvsY+otq3PnfLJeMf1hzv2OSrGaEAkGJh/9yXPOkQ+J1OxJJs9CY0fqB MvHZ98iTyeFAq+4CwKcnZxLiBchQJQd0dFPujtcoMkWgzp3QdzONdkK4P7+9XfryPECyCSUF ib2aEkuU3Ic4LYfsBqGR5hezbJqOs96ExMnYUCEAS5aeejr3xNb8NqZLPqU38SQCTLrAmPAX glKVnYyEVxFUV8EXXY6AK31lRzpCqmPxLoyhPAPda9BXchRluy+QOyg+Yn4Q2DSwbgCYPrxo HTZKxH+E+JxCMfSW35ZE5ufvAbY3IrfHIhbNnHyxbTRgYMDbTQCDyN9F2Rvx3EButRMApj+v OuaMBJF/fWfxL3pSIosG9Q7uPc+qJvVMHMRNnS0Y1QQ5ZPLG0zI5TeHzMnGmSTbcvn/NOxDe 6EhumcclFS0foHR78l1uOhUItya/48WCJE3FvOS3+KBhYvXCsG84KVsJeen+ieX/8lnSn0d2 ZvUsj+6wo+d8tcOAP+KGwJ+ElOilqW29QfV4qvqmxnWjDYQWzxU9WGagU3z0diN97zMEO4D8 SfUu72S5O0o9ATgid9lEzMKdagXP94x5CRvBydWu1E5CTgKZ3YZv+U3QclOG5p9/4+QNbhqH W4SaIIg90CFMiwARAQABiQRsBBgBCgAgFiEE4m/Wj8Ho1LYZRUZO54FXMhgMKlUFAlo2sK8C GwICQAkQ54FXMhgMKlXBdCAEGQEKAB0WIQRJbJ13A1ob3rfuShiywd9yY2FfbAUCWjawrwAK CRCywd9yY2FfbMKbEACIGLdFrD5j8rz/1fm8xWTJlOb3+o5A6fdJ2eyPwr5njJZSG9i5R28c dMmcwLtVisfedBUYLaMBmCEHnj7ylOgJi60HE74ZySX055hKECNfmA9Q7eidxta5WeXeTPSb PwTQkAgUZ576AO129MKKP4jkEiNENePMuYugCuW7XGR+FCEC2efYlVwDQy24ZfR9Q1dNK2ny 0gH1c+313l0JcNTKjQ0e7M9KsQSKUr6Tk0VGTFZE2dp+dJF1sxtWhJ6Ci7N1yyj3buFFpD9c kj5YQFqBkEwt3OGtYNuLfdwR4d47CEGdQSm52n91n/AKdhRDG5xvvADG0qLGBXdWvbdQFllm v47TlJRDc9LmwpIqgtaUGTVjtkhw0SdiwJX+BjhtWTtrQPbseDe2pN3gWte/dPidJWnj8zzS ggZ5otY2reSvM+79w/odUlmtaFx+IyFITuFnBVcMF0uGmQBBxssew8rePQejYQHz0bZUDNbD VaZiXqP4njzBJu5+nzNxQKzQJ0VDF6ve5K49y0RpT4IjNOupZ+OtlZTQyM7moag+Y6bcJ7KK 8+MRdRjGFFWP6H/RCSFAfoOGIKTlZHubjgetyQhMwKJQ5KnGDm+XUkeIWyevPfCVPNvqF2q3 viQm0taFit8L+x7ATpolZuSCat5PSXtgx1liGjBpPKnERxyNLQ/erRNcEACwEJliFbQm+c2i 6ccpx2cdtyAI1yzWuE0nr9DqpsEbIZzTCIVyry/VZgdJ27YijGJWesj/ie/8PtpDu0Cf1pty QOKSpC9WvRCFGJPGS8MmvzepmX2DYQ5MSKTO5tRJZ8EwCFfd9OxX2g280rdcDyCFkY3BYrf9 ic2PTKQokx+9sLCHAC/+feSx/MA/vYpY1EJwkAr37mP7Q8KA9PCRShJziiljh5tKQeIG4sz1 QjOrS8WryEwI160jKBBNc/M5n2kiIPCrapBGsL58MumrtbL53VimFOAJaPaRWNSdWCJSnVSv kCHMl/1fRgzXEMpEmOlBEY0Kdd1Ut3S2cuwejzI+WbrQLgeps2N70Ztq50PkfWkj0jeethhI FqIJzNlUqVkHl1zCWSFsghxiMyZmqULaGcSDItYQ+3c9fxIO/v0zDg7bLeG9Zbj4y8E47xqJ 6brtAAEJ1RIM42gzF5GW71BqZrbFFoI0C6AzgHjaQP1xfj7nBRSBz4ObqnsuvRr7H6Jme5rl eg7COIbm8R7zsFjF4tC6k5HMc1tZ8xX+WoDsurqeQuBOg7rggmhJEpDK2f+g8DsvKtP14Vs0 Sn7fVJi87b5HZojry1lZB2pXUH90+GWPF7DabimBki4QLzmyJ/ENH8GspFulVR3U7r3YYQ5K ctOSoRq9pGmMi231Q+xx9LkCDQRaOtArARAA50ylThKbq0ACHyomxjQ6nFNxa9ICp6byU9Lh hKOax0GB6l4WebMsQLhVGRQ8H7DT84E7QLRYsidEbneB1ciToZkL5YFFaVxY0Hj1wKxCFcVo CRNtOfoPnHQ5m/eDLaO4o0KKL/kaxZwTn2jnl6BQDGX1Aak0u4KiUlFtoWn/E/NIv5QbTGSw IYuzWqqYBIzFtDbiQRvGw0NuKxAGMhwXy8VP05mmNwRdyh/CC4rWQPBTvTeMwr3nl8/G+16/ cn4RNGhDiGTTXcX03qzZ5jZ5N7GLY5JtE6pTpLG+EXn5pAnQ7MvuO19cCbp6Dj8fXRmI0SVX WKSo0A2C8xH6KLCRfUMzD7nvDRU+bAHQmbi5cZBODBZ5yp5CfIL1KUCSoiGOMpMin3FrarIl cxhNtoE+ya23A+JVtOwtM53ESra9cJL4WPkyk/E3OvNDmh8U6iZXn4ZaKQTHaxN9yvmAUhZQ iQi/sABwxCcQQ2ydRb86Vjcbx+FUr5OoEyQS46gc3KN5yax9D3H9wrptOzkNNMUhFj0oK0fX /MYDWOFeuNBTYk1uFRJDmHAOp01rrMHRogQAkMBuJDMrMHfolivZw8RKfdPzgiI500okLTzH C0wgSSAOyHKGZjYjbEwmxsl3sLJck9IPOKvqQi1DkvpOPFSUeX3LPBIav5UUlXt0wjbzInUA EQEAAYkCNgQYAQoAIBYhBOJv1o/B6NS2GUVGTueBVzIYDCpVBQJaOtArAhsMAAoJEOeBVzIY DCpV4kgP+wUh3BDRhuKaZyianKroStgr+LM8FIUwQs3Fc8qKrcDaa35vdT9cocDZjkaGHprp mlN0OuT2PB+Djt7am2noV6Kv1C8EnCPpyDBCwa7DntGdGcGMjH9w6aR4/ruNRUGS1aSMw8sR QgpTVWEyzHlnIH92D+k+IhdNG+eJ6o1fc7MeC0gUwMt27Im+TxVxc0JRfniNk8PUAg4kvJq7 z7NLBUcJsIh3hM0WHQH9AYe/mZhQq5oyZTsz4jo/dWFRSlpY7zrDS2TZNYt4cCfZj1bIdpbf SpRi9M3W/yBF2WOkwYgbkqGnTUvr+3r0LMCH2H7nzENrYxNY2kFmDX9bBvOWsWpcMdOEo99/ Iayz5/q2d1rVjYVFRm5U9hG+C7BYvtUOnUvSEBeE4tnJBMakbJPYxWe61yANDQubPsINB10i ngzsm553yqEjLTuWOjzdHLpE4lzD416ExCoZy7RLEHNhM1YQSI2RNs8umlDfZM9Lek1+1kgB vT3RH0/CpPJgveWV5xDOKuhD8j5l7FME+t2RWP+gyLid6dE0C7J03ir90PlTEkMEHEzyJMPt OhO05Phy+d51WPTo1VSKxhL4bsWddHLfQoXW8RQ388Q69JG4m+JhNH/XvWe3aQFpYP+GZuzO hkMez0lHCaVOOLBSKHkAHh9i0/pH+/3hfEa4NsoHCpyy
  • Cc: Juergen Gross <jgross@xxxxxxxx>, Stefano Stabellini <sstabellini@xxxxxxxxxx>, Julien Grall <julien@xxxxxxx>, Wei Liu <wl@xxxxxxx>, Paul Durrant <paul@xxxxxxx>, Andrew Cooper <Andrew.Cooper3@xxxxxxxxxx>, Konrad Rzeszutek Wilk <konrad.wilk@xxxxxxxxxx>, George Dunlap <George.Dunlap@xxxxxxxxxx>, Marek Marczykowski-Górecki <marmarek@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, Jan Beulich <jbeulich@xxxxxxxx>, "xen-devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx" <xen-devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • Delivery-date: Wed, 27 Nov 2019 22:32:47 +0000
  • List-id: Xen developer discussion <xen-devel.lists.xenproject.org>
  • Openpgp: preference=signencrypt

Hi all,

On 11/27/19 12:13 PM, Durrant, Paul wrote:
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: Ian Jackson <ian.jackson@xxxxxxxxxx>
>> Sent: 27 November 2019 11:10
>> [...]
>> Subject: RE: [Xen-devel] [PATCH for-4.13 2/2] Rationalize max_grant_frames
>> and max_maptrack_frames handling
>>
>> Durrant, Paul writes ("RE: [Xen-devel] [PATCH for-4.13 2/2] Rationalize
>> max_grant_frames and max_maptrack_frames handling"):
>>>> -----Original Message-----
>>>> From: Xen-devel <xen-devel-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> On Behalf Of
>> Ian
>>>> Jackson
>>>> I have seen reports of users who ran out of grant/maptrack frames
>>>> because of updates to use multiring protocols etc.  The error messages
>>>> are not very good and the recommended workaround has been to increase
>>>> the default limit on the hypervisor command line.
>>>>
>>>> It is important that we don't break that workaround!
>>>
>>> Alas it has apparently been broken for several releases now :-(
>>
>> I guess at least in Debian (where I have seen this) we haven't
>> released with any affected versions yet...
> 
> I believe the problem was introduce in 4.10, so I think it would be prudent 
> to also back-port the final fix to stable trees from then on.

Yes, the max grant frame issue has historically always been a painful
experience for end users, and Xen 4.11 which we now have in the current
Debian stable has made it worse compared to previous versions indeed.

Changing the hypervisor command line worked in the past, and now that
value is overwritten again by a lower value in the toolstack, which
requires setting per-domU settings, or, what I did, just additionally
also setting max_grant_frames in /etc/xen/xl.conf to the same value as
the hypervisor command line.

This change is very welcome, even to 4.11-stable if possible, since it
will not break existing configuration of users.

If changing only the value of the hypervisor command line works again,
then old information that shows up when the users searches the web will
be useful again, which is good.

Hans

P.S. Now I'm curious to figure out what a maptrack frame is, didn't hear
about that one before.

_______________________________________________
Xen-devel mailing list
Xen-devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.xenproject.org/mailman/listinfo/xen-devel

 


Rackspace

Lists.xenproject.org is hosted with RackSpace, monitoring our
servers 24x7x365 and backed by RackSpace's Fanatical Support®.