[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [Xen-devel] [PATCH] x86/EPT: adjustments for redundant function arguments


  • To: Jan Beulich <jbeulich@xxxxxxxx>
  • From: George Dunlap <george.dunlap@xxxxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Fri, 20 Dec 2019 14:58:19 +0000
  • Authentication-results: esa5.hc3370-68.iphmx.com; dkim=none (message not signed) header.i=none; spf=None smtp.pra=george.dunlap@xxxxxxxxxx; spf=Pass smtp.mailfrom=George.Dunlap@xxxxxxxxxx; spf=None smtp.helo=postmaster@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
  • Autocrypt: addr=george.dunlap@xxxxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= mQINBFPqG+MBEACwPYTQpHepyshcufo0dVmqxDo917iWPslB8lauFxVf4WZtGvQSsKStHJSj 92Qkxp4CH2DwudI8qpVbnWCXsZxodDWac9c3PordLwz5/XL41LevEoM3NWRm5TNgJ3ckPA+J K5OfSK04QtmwSHFP3G/SXDJpGs+oDJgASta2AOl9vPV+t3xG6xyfa2NMGn9wmEvvVMD44Z7R W3RhZPn/NEZ5gaJhIUMgTChGwwWDOX0YPY19vcy5fT4bTIxvoZsLOkLSGoZb/jHIzkAAznug Q7PPeZJ1kXpbW9EHHaUHiCD9C87dMyty0N3TmWfp0VvBCaw32yFtM9jUgB7UVneoZUMUKeHA fgIXhJ7I7JFmw3J0PjGLxCLHf2Q5JOD8jeEXpdxugqF7B/fWYYmyIgwKutiGZeoPhl9c/7RE Bf6f9Qv4AtQoJwtLw6+5pDXsTD5q/GwhPjt7ohF7aQZTMMHhZuS52/izKhDzIufl6uiqUBge 0lqG+/ViLKwCkxHDREuSUTtfjRc9/AoAt2V2HOfgKORSCjFC1eI0+8UMxlfdq2z1AAchinU0 eSkRpX2An3CPEjgGFmu2Je4a/R/Kd6nGU8AFaE8ta0oq5BSFDRYdcKchw4TSxetkG6iUtqOO ZFS7VAdF00eqFJNQpi6IUQryhnrOByw+zSobqlOPUO7XC5fjnwARAQABtCRHZW9yZ2UgVy4g RHVubGFwIDxkdW5sYXBnQHVtaWNoLmVkdT6JAlcEEwEKAEECGwMFCwkIBwMFFQoJCAsFFgID AQACHgECF4ACGQEWIQTXqBy2bTNXPzpOYFimNjwxBZC0bQUCXEowWQUJDCJ7dgAKCRCmNjwx BZC0beKvEACJ75YlJXd7TnNHgFyiCJkm/qPeoQ3sFGSDZuZh7SKcdt9+3V2bFEb0Mii1hQaz 3hRqZb8sYPHJrGP0ljK09k3wf8k3OuNxziLQBJyzvn7WNlE4wBEcy/Ejo9TVBdA4ph5D0YaZ nqdsPmxe/xlTFuSkgu4ep1v9dfVP1TQR0e+JIBa/Ss+cKC5intKm+8JxpOploAHuzaPu0L/X FapzsIXqgT9eIQeBEgO2hge6h9Jov3WeED/vh8kA7f8c6zQ/gs5E7VGALwsiLrhr0LZFcKcw kI3oCCrB/C/wyPZv789Ra8EXbeRSJmTjcnBwHRPjnjwQmetRDD1t+VyrkC6uujT5jmgOBzaj KCqZ8PcMAssOzdzQtKmjUQ2b3ICPs2X13xZ5M5/OVs1W3TG5gkvMh4YoHi4ilFnOk+v3/j7q 65FG6N0JLb94Ndi80HkIOQQ1XVGTyu6bUPaBg3rWK91Csp1682kD/dNVF3FKHrRLmSVtmEQR 5rK0+VGc/FmR6vd4haKGWIRuPxzg+pBR77avIZpU7C7+UXGuZ5CbHwIdY8LojJg2TuUdqaVj yxmEZLOA8rVHipCGrslRNthVbJrGN/pqtKjCClFZHIAYJQ9EGLHXLG9Pj76opfjHij3MpR3o pCGAh6KsCrfrsvjnpDwqSbngGyEVH030irSk4SwIqZ7FwLkBDQRUWmc6AQgAzpc8Ng5Opbrh iZrn69Xr3js28p+b4a+0BOvC48NfrNovZw4eFeKIzmI/t6EkJkSqBIxobWRpBkwGweENsqnd 0qigmsDw4N7J9Xx0h9ARDqiWxX4jr7u9xauI+CRJ1rBNO3VV30QdACwQ4LqhR/WA+IjdhyMH wj3EJGE61NdP/h0zfaLYAbvEg47/TPThFsm4m8Rd6bX7RkrrOgBbL/AOnYOMEivyfZZKX1vv iEemAvLfdk2lZt7Vm6X/fbKbV8tPUuZELzNedJvTTBS3/l1FVz9OUcLDeWhGEdlxqXH0sYWh E9+PXTAfz5JxKH+LMetwEM8DbuOoDIpmIGZKrZ+2fQARAQABiQNbBBgBCgAmAhsCFiEE16gc tm0zVz86TmBYpjY8MQWQtG0FAlxKMJ4FCQnQ/OQBKcBdIAQZAQoABgUCVFpnOgAKCRCyFcen x4Qb7cXrCAC0qQeEWmLa9oEAPa+5U6wvG1t/mi22gZN6uzQXH1faIOoDehr7PPESE6tuR/vI CTTnaSrd4UDPNeqOqVF07YexWD1LDcQG6PnRqC5DIX1RGE3BaSaMl2pFJP8y+chews11yP8G DBbxaIsTcHZI1iVIC9XLhoeegWi84vYc8F4ziADVfowbmbvcVw11gE8tmALCwTeBeZVteXjh 0OELHwrc1/4j4yvENjIXRO+QLIgk43kB57Upr4tP2MEcs0odgPM+Q+oETOJ00xzLgkTnLPim C1FIW2bOZdTj+Uq6ezRS2LKsNmW+PRRvNyA5ojEbA/faxmAjMZtLdSSSeFK8y4SoCRCmNjwx BZC0bevWEACRu+GyQgrdGmorUptniIeO1jQlpTiP5WpVnk9Oe8SiLoXUhXXNj6EtzyLGpYmf kEAbki+S6WAKnzZd3shL58AuMyDxtFNNjNeKJOcl6FL7JPBIIgIp3wR401Ep+/s5pl3Nw8Ii 157f0T7o8CPb54w6S1WsMkU78WzTxIs/1lLblSMcvyz1Jq64g4OqiWI85JfkzPLlloVf1rzy ebIBLrrmjhCE2tL1RONpE/KRVb+Q+PIs5+YcZ+Q1e0vXWA7NhTWFbWx3+N6WW6gaGpbFbopo FkYRpj+2TA5cX5zW148/xU5/ATEb5vdUkFLUFVy5YNUSyeBHuaf6fGmBrDc47rQjAOt1rmyD 56MUBHpLUbvA6NkPezb7T6bQpupyzGRkMUmSwHiLyQNJQhVe+9NiJJvtEE3jol0JVJoQ9WVn FAzPNCgHQyvbsIF3gYkCYKI0w8EhEoH5FHYLoKS6Jg880IY5rXzoAEfPvLXegy6mhYl+mNVN QUBD4h9XtOvcdzR559lZuC0Ksy7Xqw3BMolmKsRO3gWKhXSna3zKl4UuheyZtubVWoNWP/bn vbyiYnLwuiKDfNAinEWERC8nPKlv3PkZw5d3t46F1Dx0TMf16NmP+azsRpnMZyzpY8BL2eur feSGAOB9qjZNyzbo5nEKHldKWCKE7Ye0EPEjECS1gjKDwbkBDQRUWrq9AQgA7aJ0i1pQSmUR 6ZXZD2YEDxia2ByR0uZoTS7N0NYv1OjU8v6p017u0Fco5+Qoju/fZ97ScHhp5xGVAk5kxZBF DT4ovJd0nIeSr3bbWwfNzGx1waztfdzXt6n3MBKr7AhioB1m+vuk31redUdnhbtvN7O40MC+ fgSk5/+jRGxY3IOVPooQKzUO7M51GoOg4wl9ia3H2EzOoGhN2vpTbT8qCcL92ZZZwkBRldoA Wn7c1hEKSTuT3f1VpSmhjnX0J4uvKZ1V2R7rooKJYFBcySC0wa8aTmAtAvLgfcpe+legOtgq DKzLuN45xzEjyjCiI521t8zxNMPJY9FiCPNv0sCkDwARAQABiQI8BBgBCgAmAhsMFiEE16gc tm0zVz86TmBYpjY8MQWQtG0FAlxKNJYFCQnQrVkACgkQpjY8MQWQtG2Xxg//RrRP+PFYuNXt 9C5hec/JoY24TkGPPd2tMC9usWZVImIk7VlHlAeqHeE0lWU0LRGIvOBITbS9izw6fOVQBvCA Fni56S12fKLusWgWhgu03toT9ZGxZ9W22yfw5uThSHQ4y09wRWAIYvhJsKnPGGC2KDxFvtz5 4pYYNe8Icy4bwsxcgbaSFaRh+mYtts6wE9VzyJvyfTqbe8VrvE+3InG5rrlNn51AO6M4Wv20 iFEgYanJXfhicl0WCQrHyTLfdB5p1w+072CL8uryHQVfD0FcDe+J/wl3bmYze+aD1SlPzFoI MaSIXKejC6oh6DAT4rvU8kMAbX90T834Mvbc3jplaWorNJEwjAH/r+v877AI9Vsmptis+rni JwUissjRbcdlkKBisoUZRPmxQeUifxUpqgulZcYwbEC/a49+WvbaYUriaDLHzg9xisijHwD2 yWV8igBeg+cmwnk0mPz8tIVvwi4lICAgXob7HZiaqKnwaDXs4LiS4vdG5s/ElnE3rIc87yru 24n3ypeDZ6f5LkdqL1UNp5/0Aqbr3EiN7/ina4YVyscy9754l944kyHnnMRLVykg0v+kakj0 h0RJ5LbfLAMM8M52KIA3y14g0Fb7kHLcOUMVcgfQ3PrN6chtC+5l6ouDIlSLR3toxH8Aam7E rIFfe2Dk+lD9A9BVd2rfoHA=
  • Cc: Kevin Tian <kevin.tian@xxxxxxxxx>, Wei Liu <wl@xxxxxxx>, George Dunlap <George.Dunlap@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>, Andrew Cooper <andrew.cooper3@xxxxxxxxxx>, Jun Nakajima <jun.nakajima@xxxxxxxxx>, "xen-devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx" <xen-devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, Roger Pau Monné <roger.pau@xxxxxxxxxx>
  • Delivery-date: Fri, 20 Dec 2019 14:58:31 +0000
  • Ironport-sdr: lw8RF3DZGmhS/mwpDFU3wSmr88i6BXhnTBHmcDqeQHjERxYTr6OmoLjrng0f34In4M7fx3kURu HmKBHu4z5OOQrAEFW1zt6ypw52dN5Pvl3LB1YQlmoSb6/vflIggHGSEWQ9CkFqfn8PKaOrq4Gd kN1xSkgka91gOrPh77llFdqDWX1QMlnQRK7eCktn28PFsUOEKI/O1cIcKYmmNBefd1lGYbShA6 EJw3g8qO2LC6PtSFbsvmj07zMcMQKGbJAlboZPyFaAhff+F2OYFn2CiV20JnGVblFEZFYkhvzB G9Y=
  • List-id: Xen developer discussion <xen-devel.lists.xenproject.org>
  • Openpgp: preference=signencrypt

On 12/20/19 2:41 PM, Jan Beulich wrote:
> On 20.12.2019 15:26, George Dunlap wrote:
>> On 12/20/19 2:21 PM, Jan Beulich wrote:
>>> In ept_p2m_type_to_flags() passing in type and access as separate
>>> parameters can be considered an optimization, as all callers set the
>>> respective fields in the entry being updated before the call. Retain
>>> this behavior but add assertions.
>>>
>>> Signed-off-by: Jan Beulich <jbeulich@xxxxxxxx>
>>
>> In what way is it an optimization?
> 
> There's no pointer de-ref needed; the values will already come in
> via registers. And "can be considered" because possibly some
> compilers are smart enough to eliminate the pointer de-ref again
> (but then it'll still be a bitfield extract, which callers may
> be able to avoid).

Right; on the whole I'd rather let compilers do this sort of
micro-optimization, and only do this "manual" sort of optimization with
some sort of benchmarks showing that is has some kind of effect.

> 
>> I don't necessarily oppose this, but given that 3 of the 4 callers
>> literally do something like:
>>
>>     ept_p2m_type_to_flags(p2m, &e, e.sa_p2mt, e.access);
>>
>> It seems like just getting rid of the extraneous arguments might a be
>> better option.
> 
> That was my original intention as well, but iirc Andrew didn't like
> it when we discussed it back then (the context here being XSA-304).

I did a quick skim through those threads and couldn't find any comment
on this issue.  Could you point me to the mail with it?  (Or Andy, would
you care to repeat your argument?)

Ultimately the patch as it stands is only making the existing code
safer, so I'm OK with giving it my Ack if you don't want to pursue the
other option; but I'd prefer trying to understand and potentially
improve things while we're at it.  (And if there *is* a good reason for
passing in parallel parameters, it would be good to record it in a
comment so we don't have this conversation again in 3 years' time.)

 - George

_______________________________________________
Xen-devel mailing list
Xen-devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
https://lists.xenproject.org/mailman/listinfo/xen-devel

 


Rackspace

Lists.xenproject.org is hosted with RackSpace, monitoring our
servers 24x7x365 and backed by RackSpace's Fanatical Support®.